loading loading
Search this catalogue
 [?]
 [?]
 [?]
 [?]

Catalogue Entry

enlarge
Photo: © Terra Foundation for American Art
inv. 73
Brace's Rock
Alternate titles: Brace's Cove; Brace's Rock, Brace's Cove
1864
Oil on canvas
10 1/4 x 15 1/4 in. (26 x 38.7 cm)
Signed and dated lower right: F.H. Lane 1864
Commentary

This version of Brace’s Rock is an anomaly in the series. The other paintings are taken directly from the field sketch and are faithful to it—to the extent that any Gloucester resident would immediately recognize the scene. With this painting Lane has turned Brace’s Cove on its head, and while the rock, though reversed, is clearly recognizable, the other features—the sandy cove, the foreground bushes, and the reef at low tide—simply don’t exist on that side of Brace’s Rock. The coast to the south is sheer granite cliffs dropping straight into deep water. It is hard to imagine Lane with his infirmities and failing health getting anywhere near the vantage point necessary to make a drawing of Brace’s Rock from that angle. 

The rest of the scene simply does not exist and has been invented, lending the painting a surrealist feel. This is partially due to the juxtaposition of the incongruous landscape elements, but the perspective is also a bit skewed. The foreground cove with the abandoned vessel has a lower vanishing point than Brace’s Rock and the reef in front of it, which seem to hover over the still cove as if in a parallel universe. Adding to the surrealist vision is the rotting vessel on the beach, which looks as if a summer party stepped ashore for a picnic years ago and never returned.

While idealized or invented landscapes were common in nineteenth-century American art, for Lane they were very unusual. He had at least five commissions for Brace’s Rock paintings from his drawing, and presumably any patron who had commissioned a work would know the scene and expect a reasonably faithful representation. Infrared photography by the Cleveland Museum of the drawing on the canvas under the painting may have solved this mystery (see below).

The underdrawing shows mountains on the horizon identical to the Camden Hills in Maine, a subject Lane painted and drew numerous times. There are also major changes to the foreground cove and rocks, all well beyond Lane’s usual minor adjustments. On first seeing the underdrawing, Lane scholar John Wilmerding immediately connected the hills in the background with the Owl’s Head masterpiece of 1862, painted just two years before this work (see below). The foreground cove is also similar to those along the shore of the island from which Lane took the Owl’s Head view.

Is the mystery as simple as Lane having had a canvas of an identical size to the other Brace’s Cove paintings in his studio on which he had started and then abandoned an Owl’s Head painting? Did he then leave the beach, rocks, and foreground boat in place, paint out the mountains, and add the reef and Brace’s Rock, but facing the other way because the position of the beach and boats demanded it? That could also explain the oddly different worlds and perspective of the beach from the rock and reef beyond: they were painted at different times in different paintings.  

X-ray image showing detail of mountains in underdrawing.
X-ray image showing detail of mountains in underdrawing. Cleveland Museum of Art; Terra Foundation for American Art.

X-ray image with underdrawing of mountains and rocks highlighted.
X-ray image with underdrawing of mountains and rocks highlighted. Cleveland Museum of Art; Terra Foundation for American Art. 

Enhanced to show similar outline of mountains.
Camden Mountains from the South West, 1855 (inv. 170) enhanced to show similar outline of mountains. Cape Ann Museum.

This is an interesting subject for speculation, all the more so for its being so unusual in Lane’s work. After all, he made interesting variations on three of the other versions, and six identical copies of anything can be tedious, even for Lane. He may have taken a convenient shortcut. Whatever its genesis may have been, this is a strange and wonderfully realized painting. Lane clearly spent time and effort on it and considered it a finished work worthy of signing and dating.

– Sam Holdsworth

Supplementary Images
Brace's Rock, 1864 (inv. 73). X-ray image showing underdrawing
X-ray image showing underdrawing
Photo: Cleveland Museum of Art; © Terra Foundation of American Art
Brace's Rock, 1864 (inv. 73). IR scan
IR scan
Photo: Cleveland Museum of Art; © Terra Foundation for American Art
Brace's Rock, 1864 (inv. 73). IR scan
IR scan
Photo: Cleveland Museum of Art; © Terra Foundation for American Art
Brace's Rock, 1864 (inv. 73). x-ray
x-ray
Photo: Cleveland Museum of Art; © Terra Foundation for American Art
Related Work in the Catalogue
loading
Explore Catalogue Entries by Keywords view all keywords »

Historical Materials

Below is historical information related to the Lane work above. To see complete information on a subject on the Historical Materials page, click on the subject name (in bold and underlined).
[ top]
PDF
view ]
publication
Report on scholars' gathering in association with the exhibition Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries
John Wilmerding, Karen Quinn, Marcia Steele et al.

November 15, 2007 Unpublished report Cape Ann Museum, Spanierman Gallery

Report on Scholars' Gathering in Association with the Exhibition Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries, organized by Cape Ann Museum, Gloucester, Massachusetts, in partnership with Spanierman Gallery, and curated by Professor John Wilmerding.

[ top]

Brace’s Rock protrudes off the eastern shore of Eastern Point at the mouth of Brace’s Cove, a small and deceptively peaceful cove with a lovely crescent beach set in the otherwise rockbound coast of the eastern arm of Gloucester Harbor, about a mile north of the harbor entrance. Belying the serenity of Lane’s paintings, Brace’s Rock, the cove and the ledge forming its northern arm was one of the worst sailing hazards on the entire New England coast. This shore was the scene of countless shipwrecks and loss of life due to its appearance from the sea as a false entrance to Gloucester Harbor. Infamously known as False Point in the days of sail, lookouts on board ship peering through bad weather would see traces of Gloucester harbor and ships at anchor over the low lying land and Niles Pond that separate Brace's Cove from the harbor. They would guide the vessel around what they thought was the end of Eastern Point into the harbor. A reef of rocks jutting across the entrance to Brace Cove brought innumerable ships to grief in this manner. Nowhere on Cape Ann is the illusion of the wild ocean seemingly tamed by a sheltering bay more tragically real than Brace’s Cove seen on a still summer afternoon as Lane has painted it.

In Lane’s day Brace's Cove was still a wild and untouched area of Cape Ann, part of the privately owned Nile’s Farm, and was unvisited by tourists and unsuited for maritime interests. Lane did his drawings from the coast just north of the cove, not from the beach where most would assume he did the drawing. Brace's Rock looks identical from either vantage point.

photo (current)
Brace's Rock, Brace's Cove, Gloucester
Image: Photo © 2011 Winston Boyer

Also filed under: Site Photographs »

[+]
photo (historical)
Brace's Rock, Eastern Point
From Gloucester Picturesque, published by Charles D. Brown.
[+]
photo (historical)
Schooner wrecked off Brace's Rock
c. 1800
Photograph
Cape Ann Museum Library & Archive
[+]
[ top]

Sloops are one-masted sailing vessels which, in American examples, set fore-and-aft sails but usually no square sails. Thus, staysails, or jibs, are set from the fore stay(s) and a quadrilateral mainsail is set from the mast and spread by a gaff and a boom. The larger sloops would often set a triangular topsail over the main sail. (1)

The sloops depicted by Lane were used in various coastal trades, each with its own requirements, which dictated the sizes and details of their hulls and rigs. Most elegant were the packet sloops, which transported passengers, mail, and higher value goods between specific ports on regular schedules. They usually measured between sixty and seventy-five feet on deck, as dictated by anticipated shipping volume. Finely finished, they usually had stern galleries—a row of windows across the transom with ornamental moldings—and varied color schemes. Examples of packet sloops are in Gloucester Harbor from Rocky Neck, 1844 (inv. 14) (center, middle ground) and Study of Ships, 1851 (inv. 141) (foreground), both of which probably made trips between Gloucester and Boston, or Gloucester and Newburyport. (2)

Another specialized sloop of similar size was the stone sloop, used to ship granite blocks from stone-loading piers around Cape Ann to other ports. They were similar in rig to packet sloops, but of heavier construction with greater hold capacity and absence of decoration. Their stout appearance was augmented by simple color schemes, or even tarred topsides, reflecting the wear and strain imposed by their heavy cargos. Lane depicted these vessels in his painting of Fresh Water Cove from Dolliver's Neck, Gloucester, Early 1850s (inv. 45), with a sloop (at left) preparing to load at wharf-side, and another (at right) sailing out with a cargo. (3)

Sloops of the more work-a-day sort are the most commonly seen examples in Lane’s paintings, most of them appearing in his views of Boston Harbor. Usually deep-loaded and looking weather-worn, they contrast sharply with the packet- and clipper ships which dominate the scene. Sloops of this type are rarely seen in Lane’s paintings of Gloucester Harbor and the Maine coast, although they were certainly needed for short-distance transportation (see Bear Island, Northeast Harbor, 1855 (inv. 24), View of Camden Mountains from Penobscot Bay, c.1852 (inv. 207), Sunrise on the Maine Coast, Mount Desert Island, 1856 (inv. 295)). For coastal Maine, lack of railroads for heavier freight and greater distances between ports made the use of schooners with larger carrying capacity a greater necessity. (4)

In Lane’s views of New York Harbor, a regional sloop variant, the Hudson River Sloop, appears in New York Harbor, c.1855 (inv. 46) (bow view, left) and A Calm Sea, c.1860 (inv. 6) (stern view, right). This type had become prominent in the Hudson River packet trade between New York City, Albany, and beyond to points north and west as far as the eastern terminus of the Erie Canal.  Large vessels for their rigs, they were well-finished and well-kept, reflecting pride of ownership and rivalry among their owners and crews. (5)

– Erik Ronnberg

References:

1. A Naval Encyclopaedia (Philadelphia: L.R. Hamersly & Co., 1884. Reprint: Detroit, MI: Gale Research Company, 1971), 59.  See first definition of "sloop" and definition of "sloop-rigged."

2. Robert Greenhalgh Albion, William A. Baker, and Benjamin Woods Labaree, New England and the Sea (Mystic, CT: Mystic Seaport Museum, 1972; reprinted in 1994), 127–28.

3. Howard I. Chapelle, The History of American Sailing Ships (New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 1935), 300–02.

4. Ibid., 300.

5. Ibid., 298–300.

illustration
Sloop
Engraving in R. H. Dana, The Seaman's Friend, 13th ed. (Thomas Groom & Co. Publisher, 1873)

A sloop has one mast, fore-and-aft rigged.

[+]
publication
Bermudian sloop
1884
A Naval Encyclopaedia:
Dictionary of nautical words and phrases
Special Articles on Naval Art and Science
Philadelphia: L.R. Hamersly & Co.

'Mudian, "Mugian, or Bermudian. A boat special to the Bermuda islands, usually decked, with the exception of a hatch; from 2 to 20 tons burden; it is short, of good beam, and great draft of water abaft, the stem and keel forming a curved line. It carries an immense quantity of ballast. Besides a long main- and short jib-boom, it has a long, taperking, raking mast, stepped just over the forefoot, generally unsupported by shrouds or stays; on it a jib-headed mainsail is hoisted to a height of twice, and sometimes three times, the length of the keel. This sail is triangular, stretched at its foot by a long boom. The only other sail is a small foresail or jib. They claim to be the fastest craft in the world for working to windward in smooth water, it being recorded of one that she made five miles dead to windward in the hour during a race; and though they may be laid over until they fill with water, they will not capsize.

[+]
artwork
Bermudian sloop in St. Georges Harbor, Bermuda
Edward James
c. 1864
St. George's Historical Society
Detail of painting of St. George's Harbour, Bermuda, during US Civil War, with a Confederate blockade runner anchored in the foreground.

Also filed under: Puerto Rico »

[+]
object
Scale model of stone sloop "Albert Baldwin"
William Niemi
c.1940
Wood, metal, cordage, cloth, paint.
Scale: ¼ in. = 1ft. (1:48)
Cape Ann Museum. Gift of Roland and Martta Blanchet (1997.17.3)

Although built in 1890 and larger than the stone sloops of Lane’s time, the "Albert Baldwin’s" hull form, rig, and loading boom are very similar to those of the 1840s and 1850s.

[+]
artwork
Silhouettes of vessel types
Charles G. Davis
Book illustrations from "Shipping and Craft in Silhouette" by Charles G. Davis, Salem, Mass. Marine Research Society, 1929. Selected images
[+]
Provenance (Information known to date; research ongoing.)
Private collection, Maine
Barridoff Galleries, Portland, Maine
Lano Collection, Washington, D.C.
Daniel J. Terra Collection, Chicago, 1983
Terra Foundation for American Art, Daniel J. Terra Collection, Chicago, 1999
Exhibition History
1980 Vatican Museum
Vatican Museum, Collection of Modern Religious Art, Rome, A Mirror of Creation: 150 Years of American Nature Painting, September 24–November 23, 1980. (Exhibition catalogue: Baur 1980), no. 14, ill. in color. Traveled to: Terra Museum of American Art, Evanston, Illinois, December 20, 1980–March 1, 1981.
1985 Terra Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Evanston, Illinois, Masterworks in American Art from the Daniel J. Terra Collection, April 27–September 12, 1985.
1986–87 National Museum
National Museum, Stockholm, A New World: American Landscape Painting, 1893–1900, September 18–November 23, 1986. Traveled to: Goteborgs Konstmuseum, Gothenburg, Sweden, December 6, 1986–February 15, 1987.
1987 Terra Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, A Proud Heritage: Two Centuries of American Art, April 21–June 21, 1987. (Exhibition catalogue: Neff, ed. 1987), pl. T-13, ill. in color, p. 122.
1988 National Gallery of Art
National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., Paintings by Fitz Hugh Lane, May 15–September 5, 1988, no. 22, ill. in color, p. 37, text, pp. 36, 39. Traveled to: Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, October 5–December 31, 1988.
1990 Terra Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, Collection Cameo, May 1990. (Terra Museum 1990).
1995 Terra Museum of American Art
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, Collection Cameo, August 1995.
1995–96 Terra Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, Attitudes Toward Nature, September 30, 1995–April 21, 1996.
2000 Musée d'Art Américain
Musée d'Art Américain, Giverny, France, Waves and Waterways: American Perspectives 1850–1900, April 1–October 31, 2000. (Exhibition catalogue: Cartwright 2000a); (Exhibition catalogue: Cartwright 2000b).
2001b Terra Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, Selections from the Permanent Collection: Two Centuries of American Art, March 10–July 1, 2001.
2002 Tate Britain
Tate Modern, London, American Sublime: Landscape Painting in the United States, 1820–1880, February 20–May 19, 2002. (Exhibition catalogue: Wilton and Barringer 2002). Traveled to: Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts, Philadelphia, June 17–August 25, 2002; Minneapolis Institute of Arts, Minneapolis, September 22–November 17, 2002.
2003b Terra Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, American Classics from the Collection, May 14–June 15, 2003.
2003 New Britain Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, New Britain Museum of American Art, New Britain, Connecticut, Copley to Cassatt: Masterworks from the Terra Collection, September 5–December 7, 2003.
2004 Terra Museum
Terra Museum of American Art, Chicago, A Narrative of American Art, February 13–October 31, 2004.
2005–07 Art Institute of Chicago
The Art Institute of Chicago, Chicago, Expanded Galleries of American Art with Loans from the Terra Foundation for American Art Collection, April 15, 2005–September 24, 2007.
2007 Cape Ann Museum
Cape Ann Historical Museum, Gloucester, Massachusetts, The Mysteries of Fitz Henry Lane, July 7–September 16, 2007. (Exhibition catalogue: Wilmerding 2007a), no. 50, ill., p. 103. Traveled to: Spanierman Gallery, New York, October 4–December 1, 2007.
Published References
Baur 1980
Baur, John I.H. A Mirror of Creation: 150 Years of American Nature Painting. New York: Friends of American Art in Religion, 1980. Exhibition catalogue (1980 Vatican Museum), no. 14, ill. in color.
Wilmerding 1980a
Wilmerding, John, ed. American Light: The Luminist Movement, 1850–1875. Washington, DC: National Gallery of Art, 1980. Exhibition catalogue (1980 National Gallery of Art), ills, fig. 7, p. 22 and pl. 11, p. 62, as Brace's Rock, Brace's Cove.
Novak 1980b
Novak, Barbara. Nature and Culture: American Landscape Painting, 1825–1875. New York: Oxford University Press, 1980, no. 10, ill. in color.
Novak 1982
Barbara, Novak. "Une Amerique Tranquille." Connaissance Arts (July–August 1982), ill. in color.
Gustafson 1983
Gustafson, Eleanor H. "Museum Accessions." The Magazine Antiques 124, no. 5 (November 1983), ill. in b/w, p. 974.
Hemphill 1984
Hemphill, Christopher. "Daniel Terra and His Collection." Town and Country (February 1984).
Sokol 1984
Sokol, David M. "The Terra Museum of American Art, Evanston, Illinois." The Magazine Antiques 126, no. 5 (November 1984), ill. in color, p. 1159.
Neff, ed. 1987
Neff, Terry A., ed. A Proud Heritage: Two Centuries of American Art. Essays by D. Scott Atkinson, et al.. Chicago: Terra Foundation for the Arts, 1987. Exhibition catalogue (1987 Terra Museum), pl. T-13, ill. in color, p. 122.
Wilmerding 1988a
Wilmerding, John. Paintings by Fitz Hugh Lane. Washington, DC: National Gallery of Art; in association with Harry N. Abrams, 1988. Exhibition catalogue, no. 22, ill. in color, text, pp. 36, 39.
Atkinson 1990
Atkinson, D. Scott. Winslow Homer in Gloucester. Chicago: Terra Museum of American Art, 1990. Exhibition catalogue, ill. in b/w, fig. 40, p. 58, text, pp. 11, 58.
Goodard 1990
Goodard, Donald. American Painting. New York: Hugh Levin Associates, 1990, ill. in color, p. 70.
Terra Museum 1990
Brace's Rock, Brace's Cove, Fitz Hugh Lane. Collection Cameo sheet. Chicago: Terra Museum of American Art, 1990. Exhibition brochure (1990 Terra Museum), ill. in b/w.
Vallino and Oraezie 1993
Vallino, Fabienne, and Charlotte Oraezie. Alle redici dell'etica ambientale: pensiero sulla natura, vilderness e creativita artistica negli Stati Uniti del XIX secolo. Rome: Universita degli Studi della Tuscia, 1993, p. 241.
Novak 1995
Novak, Barbara. Nature and Culture: American Landscape Painting, 1825–1875. Revised edition. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995, no. 10, ill. in color as insert, as Brace's Rock, Brace's Cove.
Yaegar 1996
Yaegar, Bert D. The Hudson River School: American Landscape Artist. New York: Smithmark Publishers, 1996, ills. in color, p. 51 (detail), p. 53, back cover, text, p. 50.
Cartwright 2000a
Cartwright, Derrick R. Waves and Waterways: American Perspectives, 1850–1900. Chicago: Terra Foundation for the Arts, 2000. Exhibition catalogue (2000 Musée d'Art Américain), ill. in color, p. 32, text, p. 27.
Cartwright 2000b
Cartwright, Derrick R. Rivieres et rivages: les artistes américains, 1850–1900 (text in French). Chicago: Terra Foundation for the Arts, 2000. Exhibition catalogue (2000 Musée d'Art Américain), ill. in color, p. 32, text, p. 27, as Brace's Rock.
Kennedy 2002
Kennedy, Elizabeth. "The Terra Museum of American Art." American Art Review (December 2002), text pp. 131–32.
Wilton and Barringer 2002
Wilton, Andrew, and Tim Barringer. American Sublime: Landscape Painting in the United States, 1820–1880. London: Tate Publishing, 2002. Exhibition catalogue (2002 Pennsylvania Academy); (2002 Tate Britain), cat 73, ill. in color, p. 202, text, pp. 202, 254, 270.
Bourguignon and Kennedy 2002a
Bourguignon, Katherine M. and Elizabeth Kennedy. An American Point of View: The Daniel J. Terra Collection. Chicago: Terra Foundation for the Arts, 2002, ills. in color, pp. 8, 63, ill. in b/w, p. 200, text, pp. 62, 200.
Bourguignon and Kennedy 2002b
Bourguignon, Katherine M., and Elizabeth Kennedy. Un regard transatlantique. La collection d'art américain de Daniel J. Terra (text in French). Chicago: Terra Foundation for the Arts, 2002, ills. in color, pp. 8, 63, ill. in b/w, p. 200, text, pp. 62, 200.
Slawek 2003
Slawek, Tadeusz. Revelations of Gloucester: Charles Olson, Fitz Hugh Lane, and Writing of the Place. New York: Peter Lang, 2003, Il. 9.
Wilmerding 2007
Wilmerding, John. "Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen." American Art Review 19, no. 4 (2007), pp. 171, 176.
Wilmerding 2007a
Wilmerding, John. Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries. New York: Spanierman Gallery, 2007. Exhibition catalogue (2007 Cape Ann Museum), no. 50, ills, in color, fig. 36, p. 39 and p. 103, text, pp. 24, 37, 42.
Wilmerding 2007b
John Wilmerding, Karen Quinn, Marcia Steele, et.al. Report on scholars' gathering in association with the exhibition Fitz Henry Lane & Mary Blood Mellen: Old Mysteries and New Discoveries. New York: Terra Foundaation for American Art, November 15, 2007.
Tedeschi 2008
Tedeschi, Martha, with Kristi Dahm. Watercolors by Winslow Homer: The Color of Light. Chicago: The Art Institute of Chicago, 2008. Exhibition catalogue, ill. in color, fig, 2, p. 37, text p. 37.
Neset 2009
Neset, Arne. Arcadian Waters and Wanton Seas: Iconology of Waterscapes in Nineteenth-Century Transatlantic Culture. New York: Peter Lang, 2009, ill. in b/w, p. 182, text, p. 183.
Newton 2010
H. Travers Newton, Jr. "Fitz Henry Lane's Series Paintings of 'Brace's Rock': Meaning and Technique." Terra Foundation for American Art. , as Brace's Rock.
Robbins 2021
Nicholas Robbins. "Rock-Bound: Fitz Henry Lane in 1862." Art Journal (Oxford) Volume 44, no. 1 (2021), fig. 10, p. 117.
Record last updated February 7, 2017. Please note that the information on this and all pages is periodically reviewed and subject to change.
Citation: "Brace's Rock, 1864 (inv. 73)." In Fitz Henry Lane Online. Gloucester, MA: Cape Ann Museum. www.fitzhenrylaneonline.org/catalogue/entry.php?id=73 (accessed on August 1, 2025).